You finish a draft and feel that you have done a decent job. You are quite satisfied that it finally exists, and it says what you meant to say. That finished first draft you have been chasing for the longest time. You even think, briefly, “This might work.”
Dear poet/writer, we’d love to know you better.
What are you writing?
In prose, you prefer…
To stay informed about articles related to poetry writing,
would you like to get emails from us?
We don’t spam and you can unsubscribe any time.
In prose, you prefer…
To stay informed about articles related to fiction writing,
would you like to get emails from us?
And we’re happy to throw in two free courses, too
We don’t spam and you can unsubscribe any time.
To stay informed about articles related to prose and poetry writing,
would you like to get emails from us?
And we’re happy to throw in two free courses, too
We don’t spam and you can unsubscribe any time.
To stay informed about articles related to non-fiction writing,
would you like to get emails from us?
And we’re happy to throw in two free courses, too
We don’t spam and you can unsubscribe any time.
Then you reread it the next day. That is when it hits… Suddenly, all the well-thought-out sentences feel clumsy. The metaphors look cliched and the structure feels amateurish. You just cannot believe you thought this was good. And in a flash, you feel embarrassed by the same creation that you felt satisfied with just a day ago.
So what changed? The draft is the same; it did not magically rewrite itself while you were sleeping. Your brain did… Your brain switched from creator mode to evaluator mode. Your creative mind was in charge when you were writing, and the evaluator mode switched on the moment you decided that you were done writing – so to speak. And evaluator mode is ruthless by design.
When you are writing your first draft, you are in creative mode. You follow the countless threads of thought, make the connections and create a whole new world out of random thoughts. At that point, you do not worry too much about individual sentence structure. You are just getting the ideas out to build the foundation or the skeleton for the real thing. It is quite a messy but hopeful stage where things feel possible.
But when you come back to it later, you are in your evaluator mode, and you find yourself judging every word and every sentence. The same mind that was generous while writing becomes sharp and unsympathetic while rereading. It starts picking out problems everywhere. The sentence that doesn’t quite convey what you imagined, or that paragraph that seems to drag down everything with it. The opening that excited you enough to continue writing suddenly feels extremely weak, and the turn of words that made you feel like a genius while writing feel crappy now. It is like a different personality took over.
Writing and editing are just different tasks that require you to put on different hats.
Imagine that if you walk into a house that’s still under construction and complain that the walls aren’t painted and the wiring isn’t hidden… You are just complaining about things that are not supposed to be there yet. So, think of your first draft as a construction site. If you start inspecting while you’re still building, everything looks like a flaw.
Once you see that shift for what it is, your reaction will make more sense to you.
Your writing feels worse as you improve
This one surprises people, but the more you learn about writing, the more dissatisfied you often become with your drafts.
In the beginning, everything feels because you don’t yet see all the layers that stronger writing can have. Then, as you read more and pay more attention to the craft aspect, you start noticing the pacing, the subtle tone shifts, the precarious structure, and the subtext. With time, both your eye and mind become sharper with regard to the craft. That’s when your own manuscript feels lacking.
What people overlook in such a situation is that it is a sign of growth. You are now able to see things you couldn’t see before. It feels discouraging, but the fact that you can now see where your writing falls short is an opportunity to improve. Beginners often feel more confident than intermediate writers because they’re less aware of what’s possible.
So when your draft suddenly feels “not good enough,” take it as a sign that you are better at noticing what could be better.
You may be rereading it too soon
There’s a simple reason your draft often looks terrible the moment you reread it. In that moment, you are too close to it.
When you have just finished writing your first draft, it is time to give it some time and space. All the effort you have put in it is still fresh in your mind. You remember the struggle and remember all the parts you were not sure about when you hurried through getting the ideas out onto the paper. So when you reread immediately, you tend to relive the uncertainty that came with writing them and that emotional residue colours your judgment.
Distance helps. Give it a day or two, so that the memory of the points of uncertainties fade. You can then come back as a reader and not as the exhausted person who wrestled with putting words to the ideas. The paragraph that felt embarrassing in the first place will start to look like something that is fixable.
Most writers underestimate how much timing affects perception. If you want a simple rule: don’t trust your harshest opinion of a piece if it’s less than 24 hours old.
Why sharing feels so uncomfortable
Now let’s talk about the discomfort you feel when it is time to let someone else read it. The moment your writing moves from private to public, you feel exposed. Writing is so personal. It reflects how you think, what you notice, and what you care about. Letting someone read your work feels like letting someone read you.
So your mind goes into defensive mode and starts imagining criticism immediately. It magnifies all the flaws in your head to prepare for embarrassment. You might even convince yourself the piece is terrible before anyone says a word.
Here’s the quiet truth most experienced writers know – that fear does not just disappear. You just stop taking it personally. The discomfort of being read is part of the job description.
Point to note though, is that none of this means your first draft is secretly brilliant either. First drafts are often rough, and that is how it is supposed to be. But rough is different from worthless.
Here are the practical takeaways:
1. Draft without judging.
2. Step away before evaluating.
3. When you return, look for specific issues to rectify.
4. Accept discomfort is part of the process.
The goal is not to convince yourself that everything you write is amazing. It is to stop confusing temporary discomfort with permanent ability.
A first draft rarely feels as good as you hoped it would. But that feeling is not a reflection of your ability. It is just the first step and you have a way to go before you can complete building.
One Response
I am glad I read this article before I begin editing my first draft. I really liked the analogy between a first draft and a building under construction. Also, the four takeaways are powerful. Bookmarking this article to come back to whenever I need it. Feels safe and encouraging.